Employers warned against rushing to replace departing staff
A resignation can offer businesses an opportunity to reassess roles and responsibilities, while the handling of an employee’s departure can have lasting consequences for workplace culture.
- Employer Brand
- Internal Comms
Almost one in four UK employees (24%) were actively job hunting or planning to change employer this year, according to a February 2026 survey of 2,000 workers commissioned by HR software provider Ciphr.
The findings have prompted HR consultancy Agility EOR to caution employers against rushing to replace departing staff, arguing that resignations offer an opportunity to reassess roles and workforce needs.
Employers, meanwhile, are being more cautious about hiring. Office for National Statistics figures for July to September put UK vacancies at 691,000, down 5.1% on a year earlier. CIPD’s autumn Labour Market Outlook found that 62% of employers planned to recruit in the next three months, a level close to historic lows. Half expected to maintain their current staffing levels.
That makes replacing staff even more complicated than simply filling the gap. “When someone resigns, the immediate reaction is often to ask how much it will cost to keep them, followed by how quickly they can be replaced,” says Scott Winter, chief HR officer and co-founder of Agility EOR.
The response is also being watched by the people who stay. “The way a company handles resignations is hugely important and sends a clear message about the company culture to the rest of the team,” says Katie Drake, employer brand and talent attraction expert at Dawson Walker. She says a leaving employee who is thanked and supported through a smooth handover is more likely to speak well of the company afterwards and may even return one day with more experience. A bad exit, on the other hand, can end up on Glassdoor for everyone to see.
A counteroffer or quick replacement can fix an immediate gap, but concerns around workload, management or career progression often remain. Drake says counteroffers “can damage a company’s reputation if relied on too heavily.” If staff feel the only way to get a pay raise or progress is to leave, she said, the right conversations aren’t happening. People need to feel valued “throughout their employee journey, not just when they’ve got one foot out the door.”
The same questions can continue after an employee leaves. Rather than automatically advertising an identical role, businesses can consider whether the responsibilities and skills required have changed.
“If you immediately recruit for the same role, you could end up putting someone new into a position that no longer fits the direction of the business,” Winter says.
If the role has changed, how it is described matters. “Only full transparency allows the right people to select in, or equally important, to select out,” says Drake.
A resignation may initially appear to be a staffing issue. But it can be an opportunity for employees to consider what someone left, what the remaining team needs, and whether the role still fits the direction of the organisation.